Saturday, September 30, 2023

Does Free Will Create Evil

 The concept of Free Will is a centerpiece of the freedom that God created man with in order to allow man to willfully worship him. I have read an explanation of Angels about how when God Created them, He created them to specifically worship Him. Their sole purpose was to worship and praise God. The same story seems to imply that while they were created by God, He made a mistake while creating them and by creating them with the sole purpose to worship and praise Him, they were more servants and while their purpose was to serve Him, this also caused the fall and the rebellion against God. 

The problem I have with this story is that I do not believe there is any scriptural basis to it and I cannot remember where I read it but it brings to light one of the things about mankind. Man is also made to worship and praise God but he is made in the image of God and he has the ability to make decisions using his own "free will"


Free will is the philosophical and theological concept that refers to the capacity of rational agents, typically human beings, to make choices and decisions independently and voluntarily, free from external coercion or deterministic forces. Here are some key aspects of free will:

Autonomy: Free will implies the ability to act based on one's own desires, beliefs, and intentions. It allows individuals to make choices that are not solely determined by external factors, such as physical laws, social pressures, or biological instincts.

Conscious Choice: Free will involves conscious decision-making. It means that individuals can deliberate, weigh options, and make choices that reflect their values and preferences.

Moral Responsibility: The concept of free will is closely tied to moral responsibility. If individuals have the capacity to make choices, they can be held morally accountable for their actions. Moral responsibility implies that individuals can be praised for virtuous choices and blamed or punished for wrongful actions.

Alternative Possibilities: Free will suggests that, in a given situation, an individual has genuine alternatives or options available. They can choose to act in different ways, even if external conditions remain constant.

Compatibilism and Incompatibilism: Philosophers have debated whether free will is compatible with determinism (the belief that every event, including human actions, is causally determined by prior events) or whether it is incompatible with determinism. Compatibilists argue that free will can coexist with determinism, while incompatibilists assert that free will and determinism are mutually exclusive.

Limits and Constraints: While free will allows for autonomy and choice, it does not imply absolute freedom from all constraints. Individuals may face limitations imposed by their physical abilities, social circumstances, or cultural norms. These constraints can influence the range of choices available to them.

Debate and Complexity: Free will is a topic of ongoing philosophical debate. Questions about the nature and scope of free will have implications for ethics, morality, and the understanding of human agency. Different philosophical and religious traditions offer varying interpretations of free will.

It's important to note that the concept of free will has been examined from diverse perspectives and has implications for fields such as philosophy, theology, psychology, and neuroscience. The nature and extent of free will continue to be a subject of deep exploration and discussion in these disciplines

Considering the aspects of free will mentioned earlier, it becomes evident that various factors contribute to the concept of evil. Among these descriptions, terms like "one's desires," "moral responsibility," "external conditions," and "autonomy" all emphasize the role of human decision-making in determining actions. Notably, these references often center on human choices without direct reference to God's guidance.

The question then becomes What role does Free Will play in the existence of evil?

From a Christian perspective, the concept of free will plays a significant role in understanding the existence of evil. Here's how free will is typically understood in relation to the existence of evil:

  1. Human Choice: Christian theology often emphasizes that God has granted human beings the gift of free will, allowing them to make choices and decisions independently. This gift of free will is seen as a reflection of God's love for humanity, as it enables genuine moral choices and the capacity for love, virtue, and relationship with God.

  2. Moral Responsibility: Free will implies moral responsibility. Individuals are accountable for their choices and actions, whether they choose to do good or evil. This moral responsibility aligns with the idea that humans have the capacity to make choices that affect themselves and others.

  3. The Fall: Many Christian traditions teach that the existence of evil can be traced back to the Fall of humanity. In the story of Adam and Eve, the first humans exercised their free will to disobey God's command, leading to a fallen and broken world where evil entered. This disobedience is seen as an abuse of free will.

  4. Suffering and Redemption: The existence of evil and suffering in the world is viewed as a consequence of human misuse of free will. However, Christian theology also emphasizes the redemptive aspect of God's plan. Through Jesus Christ, Christians believe that God offers the possibility of salvation and the transformation of individuals and the world. Free will plays a role in accepting or rejecting this offer.

  5. Spiritual Growth: Some Christian perspectives hold that challenges, trials, and even encounters with evil can lead to spiritual growth and moral development. Adversity can provide opportunities for individuals to choose righteousness, demonstrate love, and grow in faith.

  6. God's Sovereignty: While free will allows for human choices, Christian theology also acknowledges God's sovereignty. God remains in control over all things and can ultimately work His purposes, even in the presence of evil. Christians believe that God can bring good out of evil circumstances.

In summary, from a Christian perspective, free will is a foundational concept that helps explain the existence of evil in the world. It emphasizes human choice and moral responsibility, tracing the origin of evil to the misuse of free will. However, it also underscores the potential for redemption, spiritual growth, and the ultimate sovereignty of God in the face of evil.




No comments:

Post a Comment

Is God Tolerant? Or does He wants us to be Tolerant?

Question: Is God Tolerant? First of all I want to say, I am not entirely set on the answer to this so I wanted to explore it more. The Bibl...